The post o' Patrick Stewart Macbeth
Oct. 26th, 2010 11:07 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
a_t_rainThis will be pretty scattered, as it is Tuesday night and I can't usually do anything but scattered on Tuesdays. Short version: I liked it, but I'm not as much in love with it as the last two Shakespeare plays to hit Great Performances.
-- Lots of appearances from the witches in this, as well as from the Porter / Murderer / Seyton (whom I trust is meant to be demonic, as well). It feels like they're framing and controlling much of the action, and Macbeth really hasn't got a chance; this becomes even more overt in the final scene, in which it is clear that Supernatural Powers Are Taking A Hand.
-- Lady M is really creepy and totally in control. There are only a couple of moments that humanize her -- the "I have given suck" speech (it is clear that the child is dead, and this is lying heavily between them) and the scene with Macbeth right before Banquo's death. (I'm not sure how I feel about this -- I guess I like a few more of the cracks to be showing early on -- but it's a nice contrast with Judi Dench's interpretation. Should pair up the two versions of the "Come, you spirits" speech and show them both next time I teach this play.)
-- The pseudo-Stalinesque setting worked pretty well, I thought -- lots of concrete bunkers and surveillance and cult of personality stuff going on. That said, I think it was really a mistake to play 3.6 ("My former speeches have but hit your thoughts") as an interrogation scene in which Lennox induces Ross to give away Macduff's whereabouts -- that is NOT what is going on in the text, and what is going on is a lot more interesting and would actually dovetail much better with the whole tyranny / propaganda / doublespeak theme.
-- It must be extremely creepy to have Macbeth make you a sandwich. (There is, by the way, a LOT of dead meat in this film.)
-- Mop dance WTF? (Though I kinda liked poor nerdy Ross, who provides pretty much the only note of comedy in what is otherwise a relentlessly grim movie.)
-- They absolutely nailed 4.3 (the long scene in England where Macduff and Malcolm are feeling each other out); I sometimes think I am the only person in the world who really likes this scene, but this version has got to make a few converts. It's pitch-perfect, and they totally get what it's about.
-- Not sure what I think of Macbeth being drunk in the final scene, or about a couple of other peculiar things that happen there (which I won't spoil). That said, the rest of the final sequence is mostly very well done, esp. "Tomorrow and tomorrow" being addressed to Lady M's body.
-- Lots of appearances from the witches in this, as well as from the Porter / Murderer / Seyton (whom I trust is meant to be demonic, as well). It feels like they're framing and controlling much of the action, and Macbeth really hasn't got a chance; this becomes even more overt in the final scene, in which it is clear that Supernatural Powers Are Taking A Hand.
-- Lady M is really creepy and totally in control. There are only a couple of moments that humanize her -- the "I have given suck" speech (it is clear that the child is dead, and this is lying heavily between them) and the scene with Macbeth right before Banquo's death. (I'm not sure how I feel about this -- I guess I like a few more of the cracks to be showing early on -- but it's a nice contrast with Judi Dench's interpretation. Should pair up the two versions of the "Come, you spirits" speech and show them both next time I teach this play.)
-- The pseudo-Stalinesque setting worked pretty well, I thought -- lots of concrete bunkers and surveillance and cult of personality stuff going on. That said, I think it was really a mistake to play 3.6 ("My former speeches have but hit your thoughts") as an interrogation scene in which Lennox induces Ross to give away Macduff's whereabouts -- that is NOT what is going on in the text, and what is going on is a lot more interesting and would actually dovetail much better with the whole tyranny / propaganda / doublespeak theme.
-- It must be extremely creepy to have Macbeth make you a sandwich. (There is, by the way, a LOT of dead meat in this film.)
-- Mop dance WTF? (Though I kinda liked poor nerdy Ross, who provides pretty much the only note of comedy in what is otherwise a relentlessly grim movie.)
-- They absolutely nailed 4.3 (the long scene in England where Macduff and Malcolm are feeling each other out); I sometimes think I am the only person in the world who really likes this scene, but this version has got to make a few converts. It's pitch-perfect, and they totally get what it's about.
-- Not sure what I think of Macbeth being drunk in the final scene, or about a couple of other peculiar things that happen there (which I won't spoil). That said, the rest of the final sequence is mostly very well done, esp. "Tomorrow and tomorrow" being addressed to Lady M's body.
